Did Christ have a fallen human nature? – Part 7 of 8
by Fr. Emmanuel Hatzidakis | December 12, 2019
In another post our blogger states that Jesus was “born of a human vessel.” The most holy Virgin is not a “vessel,” a test tube. The incarnation was not “in vitro fertilization”; Jesus was not a “test tube” baby.” She conceived of the Holy Spirit, but she gestated and gave birth as any mother, yet in a supernatural and incomprehensible way, because her baby was the second person of the Holy Trinity in the flesh. She gave birth while keeping her virginity.
We now turn to other aspects of His humanness that reveal His “otherness.”
Was Christ’s humanity the same as ours?
Yes, Christ was/is 100% human, but more than that. Much more. So there were more “exceptions” in Christ. Besides His miracles, His suffering and death, and especially His bodily resurrection from the dead, they all testify that He was more than merely human. Contrary to the blogger’s assertion that Christ was a “human just like we are,” the Church’s belief is that even considered in His humanity He was above our human nature.
1) An official pronouncement of the Church
Sixth Ecumenical Synod, Synodical Epistle by St. Sophronios of Jerusalem:
“His human characteristics were above human nature… and were not [acting upon Him] tyrannically or by constraint and unwillingly, as it is with us.”
2) The witness of the Holy Scripture
- Mk. 2:10: The Son of Man has authority to forgive sins.
- Lk. 9:47: Jesus perceived the thoughts of their hearts...
- John 3:31: He who comes from above is above all…he who comes from heaven is above all.
- John 6:40: I will raise him up at the last day.
- Acts 2:27 (Ps. 16:10): For You will not abandon My soul to Hades, nor let Your Holy One see corruption.
3) The witness of the Fathers of the Church
God is not changed into human flesh or substance, but in Himself He glorified the nature that He assumed, so that human nature with its weak and mortal flesh was exalted into divine glory, whereby it possessed all power in heaven and on earth, which it did not possess before it was assumed by the Logos.
St. Gregory of Nyssa
He was born, and yet transcended our common humanity both in the manner of His birth, and by His incapacity of a change to corruption … [B]oth His birth and death were independent of the conditions of human weakness,—in fact, were above nature.
St. Dionysios the Areopagite
He is not called man as Author of men, but as being truly man in His essence. However, we do not define the Lord Jesus humanly, for He is not man only (neither beyond human essence nor of mere human essence)… [He] took substance above substance, and works things of man above man.
St. Maximos the Confessor
His flesh, united to Him hypostatically, was not human in the human way, for He was not a mere human being; but having seized the human [passions] naturally—for He had a human nature—He was carried to act not according to a natural need or constrain which is natural with us, but according to a divine authority.
4) The witness of the hymnology of the Church
Christmas Great Hours
God has appeared to men from a Virgin, assuming our form and deifying what He assumed.
5) The confirmation by Orthodox theologians
Fr. Georges Florovsky
The humanity of the Logos is different from ours: it is without sin. This has a decisive soteriological significance: Christ was exempt from the inevitability of death, and consequently His death was a voluntary death, or free sacrifice.
Fr. John Romanides
The Lord alone was exempted from this captivity [to be in a state of corruption and death], being born of the Holy Spirit and the Virgin.
These differences are not “excuses.” They constitute our faith concerning Jesus Christ, and one is not allowed to distort the truth and falsify our Orthodox faith passed on to us. Christ was sinless. We are not. So what similarity is there between us? Sinless means not that He didn’t commit any sin, but that He could not commit any sin. He had a sinless nature. Not because natures have or have not sins, but because the agent of that nature, the hypostasis (person, if you wish) of Christ’s humanity is the sinless Son of God. But if Christ’s human nature was sinless, and if death is a consequence of sin, that means He should not suffer or die (and notice, we don’t say He couldn’t, but He shouldn’t). But He did. So, what’s your answer? Our answer will be the subject of our next and final post.
- A “mercy” or an “offering” of peace? – PART II - March 26, 2020
- Resemblance to animals but affinity with God - March 26, 2020
- A “mercy” or an “offering” of peace? – Part I - March 7, 2020
- Unbaptized spouses: welcome to the Church! –Abp. Elpidophoros - February 29, 2020
- Eternal suffering or eternal rewards - February 17, 2020
- There is only one way to reach salvation and life eternal - February 17, 2020
- The practice of reading “inaudibly” does not make sense - February 10, 2020
- A symbol or actual body and blood? - January 29, 2020
- A Prayer for the Coming New Year - January 2, 2020
- Did Christ have a fallen human nature? – Part 8 of 8 - December 12, 2019